She was awake before the alarm, dressed before the light, and standing at the kitchen window with tea she hadn't drunk when Callum's Land Rover came up the track at eight-forty, a full twenty minutes early.
Fenn took the camera bag. She had zipped the logbook inside the inner pocket, between the folded blackout fabric and the spare battery, and she had told herself twice that morning that this was only because she planned to return it to the place beneath the floorboard once the walk was over. The lie had gone soft and worn in the repeating.
Callum didn't get out of the vehicle. He leaned across and pushed the passenger door open, and that was the whole of the greeting.
"You've got the footage," he said, before she had the belt on. The diesel was loud enough that he didn't have to look at her.
"I've got the footage."
"From the breakwater."
"You know what's on it. You were standing in it."
He pulled the vehicle round, tyres spitting gravel, and took the coast road south with the windows down, as though the noise could do the talking. The bay lay flat and pewter on Fenn's left, the burn cutting a thin pale line across the mud to the works, and up behind the storage yard the lamp standard stood dark, still switched off, a piece of nothing she couldn't stop seeing.
They drove a mile. Then he turned off at the passing place, killed the engine, and sat with both hands on the wheel.
"I'm asking you to stop," he said.
"Stop filming."
"Stop the whole thing. The bay, the drain, the testimonials. Take it back to Glasgow."
It was the first time he had said it plainly, and the plainness of it landed worse than any of his silences.
"Thursday's walk is in forty minutes," Fenn said. "You offered it."
"I'm withdrawing it."
"Then I'll walk it myself."
"They'll stop you at the gate. And if you go over the fence they'll photograph you going over the fence, and that becomes the story, and the story is a woman from away trespassing on a works that employs forty people on an island that's dying for the want of forty jobs. You know that. You've made films before."
"You know what's coming out of that pipe," she said. "You watched it come out. You stood there at midnight and watched it with me and then you told me to get off the pier."
"I told you to get off the pier because I wasn't going to be standing next to you when someone switched the lights back on."
"So what is it. What are you protecting."
He didn't answer that. He got out and walked to the front of the vehicle and stood with his back to her, looking down the road toward the works, and Fenn got out too, because sitting in a stopped car asking questions of a man's spine was worse than standing.
"You signed the form," she said. "The ballast log. You witnessed discharges and you signed a version that doesn't match the one on the ship."
"Don't."
"You told me yourself. You brought me the copy. Why would you bring me the copy if you wanted me to stop."
He turned round then. His face in the flat morning light looked older than it had on the breakwater, or maybe that was tiredness, or maybe it was the thing he'd been holding under it.
"Because I wanted you to understand there's two of everything," he said. "Two forms, two logs, two versions. The one that goes to the council and the one that stays on the ship. I signed the one I was given. My name's on the bottom of it in my own hand, and it's the wrong one."
"So tell the council."
"I can't."
"You can walk into Stornoway and say the form was altered and you knew when you signed it. That's the whole thing. That's the film."
"That's my job," he said. "That's the pier. That's every boat that ties up there, and the yard, and the two lads on the loader, and Donnie on the office phone taking bookings from people who don't care what's in the water as long as their fish comes out of it. I sign that form at the end of every ballast discharge for as long as I'm shore witness. If I say it was wrong, I said it was wrong every time for six years."
"Then say that too."
"You're asking me to stand up in a room and say I've been signing false records for six years and did nothing. You want that on camera."
"I want it on camera," Fenn said, and heard her own voice go hard, and didn't soften it. "I want the real thing on camera. I've spent nine years filming the real thing. I didn't come here to make a film that's true enough."
"Then you won't mind doing it without me."
"I don't need you to hold the gate open."
"No," Callum said. "You didn't need me at all. You turned up on an island, and the whole place decided you were somebody's, and you let it, because it meant a bed, and a kitchen, and a door that opens. That was fair enough. That was your work. But the work is done being fair now."
The words went in somewhere under the ribs. Fenn stood very still and made herself not look away from him.
"That's not why I stayed," she said.
"Isn't it."
"No."
"Then why."
She didn't have it. That was the worst of it — she had a camera, a chart, a hull number written in pencil, a wet logbook in her bag that she hadn't shown him and never would, and no answer at all to a question she had been not-asking herself for three weeks.
"Because it's the wrong film if it's polite," she said at last. "Because I promised a nineteen-year-old girl I wouldn't cut it to please the man paying for it. Because somebody reported that burn and nobody came, and that's still going on, and someone has to come."
Callum's head came up at that. Something moved across his face and was put away again, fast, the way you'd palm a thing off a table.
"Somebody reported it," he repeated. "Where'd you get that."
Fenn's mouth closed. Too late; she saw him reading the closing.
"Where."
"Off a page," she said. "Off a page and a bad feeling."
"Fenn."
"You've got a version and I've got a version," she said. "You keep yours."
They stood on the road with the bay behind them and the works ahead, and the wind came off the water with nothing in it but salt, and neither of them said anything for a while.
"You stop filming the bay," he said finally. "That's all I'm asking. Not the lighthouse. Do the lighthouse. The tower, the glass, the last keeper, the whole thing, I'll help you with it. I'll carry the tripod. I'll stand in your shot and look wistful. Do the thing you came here for."
"No."
"Fenn."
"No," she said again. "You want me to be the woman who came to film a lighthouse. That's a lovely film. It's a lovely film and in two years there'll be nothing left in that bay to film, and the lighthouse will still be standing, and I'll have made a lovely film about the wrong thing."
"Then we've nothing to say to each other."
"Apparently not."
He was about to say something else — his mouth had opened, his hand had come up, and whatever it was, she never heard it, because from the doorway of Ewan's cottage, thirty feet behind them, up the track, the brass bell rang.
Once. A single flat note that broke on the wind and went into the stone.
Callum stopped as if a switch had been thrown. His hand came down. His face closed, and not the way it closed when he was angry — differently, blanked, like a screen when the power cuts. Fenn turned and looked and there was Ewan standing in the sunken doorway with the door half open, one hand still on the rope, watching them without any expression she could read.
"Fenn," he said. Just that.
She looked at Callum. Callum looked at the road.
"I'll walk back," she said.
He didn't offer the vehicle. She took her bag off the floor of the cab, and she felt the weight of it, logbook and camera, and she walked up the track past Ewan, who stood aside to let her by and said nothing at all. Behind her the engine turned over, once, and then away.
She didn't go into the cottage. There was too much of it to go into — the loose floorboard, the window measured for blackout, the bundle she had taken out of the house and could not now put back without being seen. She stood in the yard for a minute and then got out her phone and rang Sorcha.
"Can I sleep on your sofa tonight," she said.
There was a pause on the line, and the sound of something being shifted in the background, and Sorcha's voice, thin and steady, the way it was every time they talked now.
"Fenn."
"Yes."
"Bring your kit," Sorcha said. "Not just a bag."