Callum was sitting on the low wall outside the bothy when Fenn came out, and he had the letter with him still, folded twice, held down against his knee by the wind.
She'd expected him to have gone. The rain had stopped and the sky over Orasay had gone the colour of wet slate, low and moving fast, and men on this island went home when a thing was done. He hadn't gone. He'd sat down on her wall like he was waiting out a tide.
"Ewan's inside," she said. "He's doing the dishes. He told me he doesn't trust me to get the order right."
"Aye, that's him testing you." Callum didn't look up. "If you put the big plates in the top rack he'll know you're no' paying attention."
Fenn sat down on the wall a foot away from him, which was close enough that she could see the letter was creased along the same line every time, folded and unfolded, folded and unfolded. He'd been doing it in the kitchen too, while the three of them sorted out Thursdays.
"I've been thinking since yesterday," he said.
"So have I."
"I'd rather say mine first, if it's the same to you." He turned the letter over. "Because if I hear yours first I'll only be answering it, and I want to know what I actually think."
Fenn put her hands under her thighs to keep them warm. "Go on."
He took a breath like a man going into cold water. "The form. The way I understand it, there's two things being asked. One is whether the money was claimed on a false statement. The other is whether the money got spent on the thing it was for." He flattened the letter against his knee. "Now. My mother wrote in the margin of that log for years because she said the signed page was a trap — she'd write the truth in the margin and sign the page, and nobody ever looked at the margin, which is why she kept doing it. And when she left she nailed those pages behind a board so they'd be found by someone and no' by just anyone."
"And they were found by you."
"They were found by me." He said it flatly. "Which means the paperwork in that house has been wrong a long time. Not evil. Wrong. Filed wrong, entered wrong, copied off old forms by a woman who didnae trust what she was copying, and then by me, who doesnae read what he signs. That's no' fraud. That's a clerical mess with a widow's handwriting all through it."
Fenn watched the light come up on the water and go out again. "You want to appeal on the basis that it was misfiled."
"I want to appeal on the basis that we've been keeping the man alive on that subsidy for three years, and if there's a clerk in Inverness who thinks the form's the problem, then the clerk should come and look at my brother's inhaler box and tell me what's fraudulent about a Thursday."
The wind took the edge of the letter and he caught it without looking.
"What's the other thing," Fenn said. "You said two."
"The other thing is that I'd need someone to put it in writing." He looked at her for the first time since she'd come out, and his face was doing something careful, the way you hold a cup too full. "I can talk all day. I can stand in a room and say it. But you put a page in front of me and the letters swim. They swim, Fenn. They've always swum. And an appeal goes on pages."
"You want me to write it."
"I want you to represent me. There's a difference, and I've thought about which one I'm asking for." He held the letter up. "MacKay said there's a review. He never said who speaks to it. If the household appeals the suspension, someone has to stand up for the household, and I'll do that in a room with my hat in my hands, but I need the pages done right or they'll bury us in procedure by Friday."
"And if I do it."
"Then it gets done right." He said it like a fact, not a compliment. "But there's a thing I have to say before you answer, because it's the reason I sat out here instead of knocking."
"Say it."
"You're making a film." He watched her. "You're building something with that footage, and it's got my mother's name on the edge of it, and my brother's name in it whether he knows or not, and the bay, and the pipe, and a diver with his face turned away. And if I ask you to stand up for this household, I'm asking the same person who's out on the water at six with a camera to be the person who signs our name to a paper. Those two might want different things."
Fenn didn't answer straight away, because he was right and he'd said it cleanly and a lie would have been easy and wrong.
"They might," she said. "But I'll tell you what I said to Ishbel and what I'd say to any of it. I'm not stopping filming."
"I'd never ask you to stop."
"You might, in a fortnight."
"I might." He turned the letter over again. "So put it in. Whatever you're going to do with the camera, put it in the appeal, in your own hand, from the first page, saying the household's case is the household's and the film is the film, and they're not to be traded for each other. So when someone reads it they know there's a woman filming and a man asking, and neither of them is hiding the other."
Fenn looked at the bothy door, where the light was on and Ewan was inside doing the dishes in the correct order.
"He'll want it written down," she said.
"He'll want three copies."
"He'll want it in capitals."
"Aye. THURSDAYS." Callum almost smiled. "That's the other thing. You and me are going to have to be honest with each other in front of him, or he'll know, and then he'll make us sit down and write out what we're actually saying."
"Then let's start as we mean to go on." Fenn stood up, and the cold came back into her legs. "All right. Conditions."
He raised his eyebrows.
"One. I do the pages, but every page goes to you before it goes anywhere, and you strike out anything you can't stand behind in a room. Not because it's wrong. Because you have to be able to say it to MacKay's face without your voice doing anything."
"That's fair."
"Two. I don't write that the film and the case are separate and then use the case as the film. If I use anything from the appeal, I tell you first, and you get to say no, and I have to take the no. That's the part I might hate."
"That's the part I'll hold you to."
"Three." Fenn stopped. She hadn't planned a third. It came up out of her like a step on a stair that wasn't there. "When it goes wrong — and it will go wrong, because paperwork always does — nobody leaves. Nobody goes quiet for a week and comes back with the boat sold and the letter already sent. We come and we say it out loud at that table in there, in front of Ewan, with the tea going cold."
Callum looked at her a long moment. The wind came off the water and pushed her hair across her face and she let it.
"You've been thinking about the boat," she said.
"I've been doing sums."
"I know. I saw you doing them. I let you, because it wasn't my money."
"It's no' my money either, it's the boat's."
"Same thing." She held out her hand. "Three. Nobody leaves."
He got off the wall and stood in front of her, and he took her hand, and his was colder than it should have been for a man who'd been sitting out here in the wind for an hour, and the grip was careful in the way that told her he'd thought about it.
"Nobody leaves," he said.
They shook on it in the doorway, because the bothy door was behind her and the light over it was on and that was as good a place as the island offered. Through the glass, Ewan was at the sink with his sleeves pushed up, watching them steadily, and when he caught Fenn's eye he pointed at the kettle with a dripping hand. THURSDAYS, written down, three copies. He'd have the paper out.
Then Callum let go and looked past her, up the track, and his face changed.
Fenn turned.
The lighthouse was dark.
Not dim, not hooded — dark, its whole column gone out of the grey sky, so that the headland looked like a head with the eye put out, and the beam that had swept the Sound every eight seconds since before either of them was born simply wasn't there. She hadn't noticed it until this second, which was how things went on the island: you only saw the light when it stopped.
"Wednesday," Callum said quietly. "They said Wednesday for the repair."
"It's Thursday."
"Aye." He was already moving, walking away from the bothy along the track toward the lighthouse, his boots loud on the wet stone, and Fenn went after him with her heart going the way it went when the sea changed under her.
Halfway up the track they met Kenzie coming down at a run with a torch in her fist, and Kenzie saw Fenn and Callum together and still said it, straight out, no softening on it at all.
"You pair. There's a boat at the pier. Council launch." She was out of breath. "Two of them in suits and one of them's got a folder, and Mrs. Munro says the one with the folder is from the auditor's office in Inverness, and she says they've come about the subsidy — Fenn, they said your name. They asked for you by name."