The Lightkeeper's Fiancée

Chapter 51: The Third Log

Callum had the lighthouse lamp gallery to himself when she came up, the great lens hooded and cold behind him, the sea doing its slow grey work beyond the glass. He had a rag in one hand and the brass rail half-polished, which was what he did with his hands when he did not want them doing anything else.

Fenn set the envelope on the tool chest between them. She had carried it from Stornoway in the inside pocket of her jacket, and it still had the fold in it that Storrow's office had put there when they copied it, and the faint cupboard-damp smell of records that had spent a decade going nowhere.

"MacKay let me have the certified copy," she said. "Kirsty's version. The carbon. Not the one that went in."

He looked at the envelope and did not touch it. "Because the one that went in had my mother's name on it."

"Because MacKay wanted me to look at the rest of the page without a lawyer reading it over my shoulder first." She pulled her gloves off, finger by finger. "It's just the form. The 2011 interest. The box where a name goes. And below it, where the interest was logged in, the person who lodged it."

She took it out. The copy was thin grey-blue paper, softer than the original, and the carbon had bled at the corners. Callum moved the rag once around the rail, very slowly, then set it down.

"Read it," he said.

" 'Lodged by A. Rennie, Supervisory Officer, Coastal Infill Liaison.'" Fenn watched his face. "That's the name on the receiving line. Your mother's was on the interest itself."

"Aye." He said it quietly, the way a man says a thing he has known for a long time and never once said aloud. "Audrey Rennie. She was the one who signed off on the consultation response — took it off the desk and put it through the correct channel. That's why my mother's name is on it, and that's why it went where it went and not into a drawer."

"You knew this."

"I knew a name went on it that wasna her own hand. I didnae know whose till this minute." He bent to the carbon, not touching it, hands behind his back like a man at a museum case. "That's Audrey. That's her hand. The way she crossed the seven with the little hook on it. She taught my mother to cross a seven that way and my mother taught me and I've been doing it thirty years."

Fenn sat down on the low bench under the window because the floor was cold and because she wanted the room to stop tilting. "Where is she now?"

He straightened. The light off the water moved across the glass in front of him and did not touch him.

"She'll be five years dead in November," he said. "Audrey Rennie's on the mainland. She died at Lochgilphead. My mother went to the funeral and came back and didnae speak for a week."

The lamp hummed, or maybe it was the wind in the gallery vent, and Fenn let the silence have its length.

"So the supervisor's dead," she said at last. "Five years. Before any of this came up. That's why nobody's ever asked her what she meant by lodging it."

"There's nobody left to ask who was in that office," Callum said. "That's the point of it. That's why it worked. The only person who could hang a name on the lodging was the lodging, and the lodging is a carbon in a box in Stornoway and a woman in the ground at Argyll."

Fenn took the carbon back. She didn't fold it. She laid it flat on the tool chest and put her hand on it, and it was like putting a hand on something asleep.

"Supervisors keep papers," she said. "Every institution on earth has a cupboard like this. Rennie would have kept her own copies, her own correspondence, the letters she sent and the letters she got."

"If she did."

"If she did, they went to somebody when she died. Not the council — she'd have retired by then, that's the whole reason the office was thin by 2014 and nobody there remembers the file. Her own papers. Where do a dead woman's own papers go?"

Callum looked at the lens. He looked at it the way you look at a thing you have loved before you have to say something you do not want to say.

"Her widow," he said. "Morag. On the mainland, by Oban. She's ninety-something. She and Audrey were forty years together and my mother used to send them marmalade at Christmas and get a card back with a siskin on it every year, and my mother would put the siskin on the dresser and leave it there till the next one came."

Fenn did not say anything, because he was in it now, and a man walking through his own house does not want to be shouted at.

"You've met her," she said.

"Twice. At the funeral, and at my mother's, the year after." He turned his cloth over, found no clean part, set it down. "She'd have his papers or she'd not. Christ, Fenn, it's been five years. A house that old, with a woman that age — the papers could be in a box in the loft or they could have gone to the tip with the rest of it and nobody would know, and there's no way to ask her that doesnae turn up at her door with a whole bay on my back."

"So don't. I'll go."

"No."

"Callum."

"No," he said again, and it came out of him harder than either of them expected, and he stopped, and started again lower. "You're on a witness list. You've been filmed refusing an inspector on the water. Anything you turn over now, Kirsty gets to say you drove to the mainland and coached a ninety-year-old woman inside a fortnight of the hearing." He shook his head once. "And I'd rather not ask her. That's not a legal thing. I'd just rather not."

"Because of your mother."

"Because the last time I stood in Morag Rennie's kitchen it was the day after my mother's second Christmas without her and Morag gave me tea and a siskin card and neither of us said one true word the whole hour." He picked the rag back up because he needed his hands doing something. "I've thought about writing. Every year, since the hearing, I've thought about writing."

Fenn got up. She went to the window and stood beside him and together they looked out at the sound, which was empty now, or looked it.

"What would you write," she said.

" 'Dear Morag, your dead wife's signature is the only reason a man's mother got blamed for eighteen years of shite in the water, could I please have a look in her boxes.'" He exhaled, almost a laugh. "Aye. I'd post that."

"You could write and say you were thinking of her."

He was quiet.

"She'd answer that one," Fenn said. "People answer that one."

The radio on the gallery rail squawked — Tam, on the boat, saying the tide had turned early and if anybody wanted the harbour mouth with light on it they were down to the last of it. Fenn looked at her watch. Dusk was coming in sooner than it had any right to.

She folded the carbon, carefully, along its old crease, and put it back in the envelope and the envelope back inside her jacket. Then she took out her notebook and set it open on the chest where the carbon had been, and wrote, in her flat and undramatic hand, that Rennie, A., was the lodging officer, deceased 2021, papers possibly with widow at Oban, no approach yet authorised by anyone but me.

"Callum," she said. "Who else signs into that office. Who currently holds the Coastal Infill Liaison portfolio on the council."

He thought about it. It was an odd question and it took him a moment to see why she was asking it, and when he did she watched it land.

"Kirsty's counsel will call the survey adequate," she said. "Kirsty is on the record that the office ran properly. So if there's a widow in Oban holding Audrey Rennie's correspondence, that's not a favour to us. That's a subpoena with a face on it. Whoever gets to her first sets what she remembers."

Callum looked at the notebook, at the four lines she had written, and then past it, out the window, where the light was going the colour of weak tea.

"There's a boat," he said. "Oban's the MacVane berth."

"I know where Oban is."

"Then you know who they'd send if the council wanted a sympathetic chat with an old woman about her wife's filing habits." He picked up the rag and dropped it in the bucket and his hands were shaking and he did not hide it. "It'd not be a lawyer. It'd be somebody she'd open the door to."

Fenn closed the notebook. Down on the water Tam's engine coughed and settled into its idle, the sound coming up thin through the glass, and beyond the harbour line the bay lay flat and dark and full of the thing that was supposed to arrive after dark, and she stood there a moment doing the arithmetic of one night against another.

"Callum," she said. "What time does that crossing come in."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 51: The Third Log · The Lightkeeper's Fiancée · Lumen Reads