The Lightkeeper's Fiancée

Chapter 52: The Restored Page

Ewan's workshop smelled of linseed and cold iron, and he had cleared the whole of the long bench for the operation, laying down a sheet of blotting paper like a surgeon's drape.

"Hands," he said.

Fenn held hers out. He inspected them the way he inspected everything, without hurry, then set a scalpel in her right palm and closed her fingers round it.

"Not for cutting. For lifting. You'll know when."

The blue logbook sat between them, swollen shut, its boards warped into a shallow dish. Two months in the tarpaulin had done the worst of it — the pages had fused into a solid block at the spine, and when Fenn had first tried to open it back at the cottage, the paper had torn like wet bread.

"Steam first," Ewan said. He set a kettle on the little stove and wedged a wire rack over a tin basin. "Water in the kettle, not on the book. We work in the vapour. Slow. If it feels like it's fighting you, stop."

"How long?"

"As long as it takes. Your film can wait."

She didn't tell him it couldn't. She took the kettle off the boil when it began to whistle, poured, and let the steam come up around the basin in a soft column. Ewan lowered the logbook onto the rack, spine down, boards open as far as they would go without cracking.

They waited. Fenn counted the drip of condensation from the workshop's corrugated roof and made herself not reach for it.

"Now," Ewan said.

She took up the scalpel and slipped the flat of the blade between the first two pages, at the corner where a sliver of daylight showed. The paper lifted, feather by feather. She worked it up the gutter, feeling for the seam, and it came away whole, with a soft, damp sigh.

"Good," Ewan said. "Again."

They went on like that for the better part of an hour. Fenn lost count of the pages. Some came clean; some left pale ghosts of themselves behind, the ink bled out into the substrate, and she set those aside on the blotting paper in order, laid flat, weighted at the corners with brass offcuts. Ewan replenished the kettle twice. He said almost nothing. Once, when she hissed through her teeth at a page that wanted to rip, he put one thick hand flat over hers and held it until she breathed.

The early entries were routine — weather, readings, lamp checks, a tally of the oil. Alistair Macleod's hand, small and level. Then, halfway through the block, the hand changed. Looser. Tilted right. A woman's hand, Fenn thought, and her stomach went tight.

"Here," she said.

Ewan leaned in. He read a line, and then another, and his face did the thing it did when a catch came in that the boat couldn't hold — a minute closing down, no expression at all.

"March 'ninety-eight," he said. He set the reading glasses on his nose. "'Pipe one shows in the seals. Repaired at the collar, not replaced. I have said so three times. I will say it in writing.'"

He turned the page. Fenn let him.

"'Today the collar wept again. I have asked for the survey letter and been told it is not required. I am keeping this book myself in case anyone ever wants the truth of it.'"

"That's your mother's voice," Fenn said.

"That's my mother's voice," Ewan said, quiet, and did not look up.

They found the map four pages on, and even through the blur of the water damage it stopped Fenn's breath. Ellen Macbeth had drawn the bay in ink, the way she must have known it from the lamp: the two headlands, the harbour mouth, the beach, and running out from the shore the long ruled line of the outfall, older than anything on the council's plans, heading due east-north-east into the deep water. And beside it, curving off at a shallow angle, a second line, shorter, ending in a small black cross two-thirds of the way to the coast.

"Pipe one," Ewan said. He touched the page, not quite touching it. "The original. The one the lighthouse used before the mains came. She's drawn it discharging at the plume site."

Fenn's mouth had gone dry. She bent close. In the corner of the page, in the same hand, a date and a line of figures — the fall, the flow, the days since the last seal.

"That pipe's been draining into the bay since before MacVane put a hull in the water," she said.

"Aye," Ewan said.

"Since before 2011."

"Aye."

She looked at him. He was still holding the reading glasses, still looking down at his mother's hand. And there it was, the thing that had been sitting in the room since the first afternoon, the thing she had asked and he had answered with a shrug and a story about a shed and a fire.

"Ewan. The book was never burned."

"No."

"You knew where it was."

He set the glasses down on the bench, folded, deliberate. "I knew," he said.

"For how long?"

"Since the month she died. She gave it to me at the hospital, wrapped in a pillowcase, and she said, Keep this where the county can't get at it. And I did what she asked, and I did not look at it again until you came up that track with your camera and told me the water was sick."

Fenn turned the scalpel over in her fingers. She was aware of how loud the condensation was, tapping on the roof.

"Why not just — you could have walked this into the council office any day in twenty-five years."

"And they'd have burnt it for me properly," Ewan said. "Or written their own version and handed me back my copy. Your mother's word against a company lawyer, and her dead. That's not a fight you win. That's a fight that buries you." He picked up the glasses again and put them back in his shirt pocket. "I'm not a young man, Fenn. I've watched this island hand over everything it loves to keep the boats running. I could not have stood up in a room and told them Ellen Macbeth was right, when the whole place had already decided she was cracked."

"Did they decide that?"

"My brother did," Ewan said. "He said she was ill. He said it at the funeral. Half the church agreed with him."

Fenn was quiet a moment. Then she said, "And you never told Callum."

"I told Callum nothing, and he never asked, and that's how we've got on. He was nineteen. I wanted him to have his mother clean in his head, not as the woman who got laughed at for twenty years." He cleared his throat. "Look at your page. It's drying. Turn it."

She turned it.

The last entries were written in a different ink, or the same ink under a hand that had begun to shake. The dates ran into that spring — the spring before the accident, Fenn realized, and had to steady herself. The words were cramped and hard to read where the water had reached them, and she read them aloud to be sure, softly, the way you read a thing the dead have written.

"'I have written again to the office at Oban. I have kept the certified copy of my application.'" Fenn paused. "She kept it. The carbon. She kept it."

"Aye," Ewan said. "She'd have kept it."

"'If it is found,'" Fenn read on, "'let it be found with the book. Both of them tell the same tale.'" Then a date, and then a final line, and the hand had gone very difficult here, and the last word had blotted, and Fenn bent close and could not make it out.

"She was tired," Ewan said. "She wrote that the week before. She was on the night watch and she had a chest on her and she was tired."

Fenn wrote the time and the date of the last entry in her notebook, and copied each line of the map — the coordinates of the cross, the fall figures, the two pipes. She photographed every spread twice, once flat and once raking, for the relief of the ink, and put the camera away. Then she stood at the bench with her palms flat on either side of the drying book and did the arithmetic out loud, slowly, because Ewan needed to hear it and so did she.

"Old pipe, active until at least the nineties, discharging at the plume site. MacVane's outfall, in service 2011 to now, discharging at the plume site. Same seabed. Same current. Same shoal." She looked up. "The contamination predates MacVane."

"It does."

"Which means the island has its own fingerprints on this. The council's, and the estate's, and whoever kept the old light burning and never sealed that pipe."

Ewan nodded once. "That is what the book says."

"And the survey only sampled the modern outfall corridor. Nobody's looked at the old line because nobody knew it was there." She heard her own voice flatten as the shape of it arrived. "Kirsty can stand up in that hearing and say her office inherited a mess it didn't make. And she'd be telling the truth."

Ewan took the kettle off the stove and set it, dead, on the bench. "So whose side are you on, girl?"

Fenn looked at the map, at the small black cross two-thirds of the way to the coast, at the dead woman's trapped, honest hand. Then she picked up the camera and stepped out into the yard, where the evening light was going long and amber across the water, and she framed herself against the sea, because she did her worst thinking alone and in the lens.

She pressed record.

"I found the logbook," she said to the camera. "It was never burnt. The keeper drew a map of both pipes, and the old one — the one the island built, the one the lighthouse kept — discharges exactly where the new one does. Which means this bay has been fouling since before MacVane ever laid a hull in it. Which means the company is guilty, and the council is guilty, and so is the island." She looked off frame, at the water, and brought her eyes back. "I came here to make a film about MacVane. I don't know what film I'm making now."

She let the camera run a second longer, then stopped the take and kept it.

Back at the bench, Ewan was folding the blotting paper around the logbook, page by page, like swaddling. He did not look up.

"Where will you keep it," he said.

"You're asking me that now?"

"I'm asking because the boy from the boat knows you've been ferrying things to and from the mainland, and because there's a ship crossing after dark tonight, and because the first person who wants that book is standing on the pier at Oban with a favour to call in." He squared the corners of the paper. "Where will you keep it, Fenn."

Her notebook said one thing about the other problem, and the other problem was a widow in Oban with a shoebox of papers, and a visit was still a thing nobody had authorised but her.

She looked at the wrapped book on the bench, then at the dark coming down over the Sound.

"Not here," she said. "And not with me past tonight."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 52: The Restored Page · The Lightkeeper's Fiancée · Lumen Reads