Ewan had cleared the bench by the time she came back down, the paraffin lamp lit and the blue book lying open on a sheet of newspaper like something that had died and needed examining. Fenn stood at the end of the bench with her hands still cold from the harbour and looked at her mother's map for a long time without speaking.
It was drawn in pencil, the lines gone grey with water, but the shape of it was unmistakable. Ellen Macbeth had been a keeper's daughter and then a keeper's wife and then, for eleven years, a keeper's widow, and she had drawn the coastline the way someone draws a face they've known all their life. Orasay on the left, the lighthouse on its headland, the bay opening between. She'd marked the old pipe in a firm dark line running out from the rocks below the light and ending in a small cross-hatched circle, and beside the circle, in the same small hand she'd used for her weather logs, she had written *discharge point, 40 fathoms, sand and rock.*
Fenn put her own chart next to it on the bench. The laminated one from the council survey vessel, the one the inspector had refused to hand her and that Tam had photographed on the wheelhouse table while the man was in the heads.
The two circles sat side by side under the lamplight. The old pipe's discharge point. The MacVane outfall plume. They were the same circle. Ellen had drawn it forty years before MacVane laid a metre of pipe.
'She's under it,' Fenn said.
Ewan leaned in. He didn't say anything. He had the look of a man who already knew and had spent a long time not knowing what to do with it.
'Every sample they took, every test that came back clear, every time someone on that committee said it was the ferry, it was the dredging, it was seasonal —' She stopped. 'It was here first. It was here before any of them.'
She went to the window. Out past the black slope of the field the lighthouse was turning, slow and patient, throwing its sweep across the water and pulling it back. She could hear the sea but not see it. The MacVane ship was due after dark tomorrow and she still had no idea how she was going to film it without putting Tam's boat and Tam's son in the frame.
'You should sit down,' Ewan said.
'I'm fine.'
'You're white as a haddock.'
She sat down. He poured her a whisky she hadn't asked for and she drank it standing up anyway, then sat again with the glass in both hands and looked at the two circles until they stopped meaning anything and started meaning everything.
'The island will say she was ill,' Ewan said quietly. 'That's what they said then. That's what they'll say now, once the film's out. They'll say Ellen Macbeth had a bad head on her, everyone knew it, and she drew a map that's forty years old and worth nothing in a licensing hearing.'
'It's not worth nothing. The discharge point is the discharge point.'
'It's worth nothing if they can put it in the same sentence as her.' He sat down opposite her, the lamp between them. 'You know that. You know exactly what they'll do, because you've been watching them do it to your own self for a month.'
She did know. She'd watched a woman in the Co-op turn her back on her. She'd heard *the filmmaker* said in the pub the way you'd say *the weather*. She had spent a week being the stranger who came to film a dying light, and now the island was starting to look at her the way it had once looked at Ellen Macbeth — as a person who'd come to tell it something it did not want to hear.
Fenn set the glass down.
'I want you to film me,' she said.
Ewan looked up. 'What?'
'With the book. The map. Both charts. I'm going to say something on camera and I want it recorded properly, yours or mine, I don't care which.' She was already reaching for her bag, for the small camera she carried when the big one was too much trouble. 'Use mine. Tripod's in the boot.'
'Fenn.'
'Please, Ewan.'
He got the tripod. She set the camera up on the bench between the two charts and the open logbook and angled the lamp so the pencil lines showed, then stepped back and stood in front of it with her hands at her sides and did not look at Ewan at all.
She'd done this a hundred times. You set the frame, you set your voice low and level, you did not perform. You told the truth to the lens the way you'd tell it to a friend who'd asked a hard question.
'This is the lighthouse pipe,' she said. 'Ellen Macbeth drew it in July 1984. The discharge point is at these coordinates.' She read them out. 'The MacVane outfall plume sits on the same coordinates. I have it on a council survey chart dated three weeks ago.'
She paused. Behind her the lighthouse came round again, and its light crossed the back wall of the workshop like a hand passing over a face.
'I came here to make a film about a coastline and a company. I thought I knew who the villain was. I thought I knew who the island was.' She took a breath and let it out. 'But this bay was being poisoned before MacVane bought a single trawler. Ellen Macbeth knew it. She wrote it down. She tried to make someone listen and no one did, and then she died, and the pipe was forgotten, or it was *made* forgotten, and I don't yet know which. That's what I'm going to find out.'
She stopped the recording herself. The room was very quiet. Ewan was standing by the door with his arms crossed.
'You'll keep that,' he said. It wasn't a question.
'I'll keep that.'
'Even though it hands MacVane the argument? *The bay's been dirty forty years, what's a few pallets of ours on top*?'
'It doesn't hand it to them if we show the whole thing. They get a shield only if we hide the pipe. If the pipe's in the film from the start, and the tests are in the film, and the night runs are in the film, then the pipe is just one more lie the island told itself.' She looked at her mother's pencil line. 'It's the island's guilt as much as theirs. That's the only version that's true.'
Ewan pulled his coat off the hook. 'Callum will not see it that way.'
'Callum can see it any way he likes.'
'He won't like it, Fenn.'
'Then he won't like it.' She said it too fast and felt the door of her own words shut behind her. She softened. 'I'll tell him myself.'
'You'll tell him before it goes in the cut.'
'Of course I will.'
'Before the cut, Fenn.'
'I said.'
Ewan went out to walk her to the car and she made two trips: the logbook wrapped in a towel in the boot against the seat, and the charts rolled inside the plastic tube she used for plans. When she came back for the second load her phone lit up on the bench and she looked at it on the way past. A number she didn't know, an Oban area code, three missed calls. No voicemail.
She picked it up and stood with it in her palm, the back door open to the dark, the lighthouse turning over the black field.
Then she went inside and rang the number back.
It rang six times. A woman's voice, old, careful. 'Hello?'
'Hello — I'm sorry to call so late. My name's Fenn Adair, I'm a filmmaker working on Orasay. Is that Mrs Rennie?'
A pause with the sea in the line, or traffic, or something alive behind it.
'Who did you say gave you this number?'
'No one did. It was in a diary. Audrey's diary.' Fenn's heart was going harder than the question warranted. 'I'm sorry for your loss. I — there's a form. A form Audrey signed, about the bay, and I need to ask you one thing about it, just one, and then I'll never trouble you again.'
The line was silent so long that she thought the woman had put the phone down. Then the old voice came back, very close to the receiver, as if she had turned her whole face into it.
'You're not the first one to ring me about that form,' Morag Rennie said. 'A man came up from Oban last week. He brought flowers.'