The Market of Borrowed Names

Chapter 43: The Gathered Proof

Iona had taken over the kitchen table by the time Maeve got back from the off-licence with two bags of chips and a bottle of cheap red, because the office had run out of everything except instant coffee and the kind of biscuits that came free with a bank.

"Don't look at it yet," Iona said, one hand flat on the closed binder.

"I've seen the binder."

"You've seen the first ten pages. I've been busy." She moved her hand. "Sit down first."

Maeve sat. Iona opened the binder and turned it round.

The photographs were laid out in columns, six to a page, each one captioned in Iona's small neat hand: a name, an age, a date, a place the woman was last seen as herself. Underneath each photograph, a second one, usually worse — a hospital corridor, a shelter doorway, a gravestone, the back of a head walking away from a camera. Some of the second photographs were of nothing at all. An empty chair. A doorway with no one in it.

"Where did you get these?"

"Half from the parish bulletin archive in Cabra. Some from a retired nurse who used to work nights at the Mater and remembers the same three women coming back year on year, each time thinner, each time a bit less there. Some from a woman called Brigid who runs a knitting circle in Phibsborough and has been collecting names in a notebook since 1998 because she thought she was going mad." Iona pulled a sheaf of loose pages out from behind the photographs. "This is the notebook."

Maeve turned the pages. The handwriting changed every few sheets — different pens, different decades, someone's biro bleeding through from the other side. Names, dates, the same words over and over: *went quiet. Went thin. Went.*

"Brigid?"

"Brigid's mother started it. Then Brigid. Now Brigid's daughter does a page a month because Brigid's hands have gone."

"How many names?"

"Two hundred and eleven." Iona said it flatly, the way you say a number you've counted too many times. "That's the ones who left a trace. There'll be more."

Maeve took a chip, ate it, looked at the columns. The women stared out of the glossy paper in their nineties hairstyles and their 2010s hairstyles and their hair tied back for work, and none of them had anything wrong with them at all, which was the worst part. They could have been anyone's aunt. They could have been her mother.

"Your mam's not in there," Iona said, watching her. "I checked twice."

"She wouldn't be. She's been paying." Maeve turned another page. "What's in the back?"

"The back's the interesting bit."

Iona turned the binder round herself, flipped to the last twenty pages, and Maeve understood why she'd said sit down first.

Photographs, but not of women. Of the gate. Twenty-three years of it, from the same angle every time — the wall in the Phoenix Park where the bus map said there was nothing, and the gate standing in it, open in 1999, closed in 2004, open again in 2011, and so on, dated in the corner of each frame. Some of the photographs were ordinary tourist shots, blurry, taken from too far away. Others were as sharp as if the photographer had been standing at the threshold.

"Who took these?"

"Eleven different people. None of them knew each other. All of them thought they'd found something private." Iona tapped one frame. "This one's from a man called Fergal who emailed me last night after I put a post on the Phibsborough community page asking if anyone had seen anything odd in the park. He thought I was a crank. Then he sent me forty-one photographs."

"You put a post up?"

"Under a fake name. Aoife's idea."

Maeve stopped chewing. "Aoife's back?"

"Aoife never left." Iona nodded at the box room off the kitchen. "She's been in there since eight. She's got the live thing set up."

The door opened on cue, and Aoife came out with her laptop balanced on one forearm and a mug in the other hand, looking like she'd been up for two nights and enjoying it.

"You're talking about me."

"We're talking about you putting your face on a public forum to find witnesses," Maeve said.

"I put my face nowhere. Iona's the one with the fake name." Aoife set the laptop on the table, turned it round, and there it was, mid-feed: a page with sixty-odd comments under a photograph of the gate. Maeve scrolled. *I saw this in 2016.* *My sister saw this.* *I thought I was the only one.*

"Sixty-three replies," Aoife said. "Twenty of them are people who'll talk on camera. Sixteen more sent photos. Four say they'll come to the park if someone tells them when."

"You told them when?"

"I told them *soon*." Aoife sat down, pulled the binder towards her, and started flicking. "Which is the thing I need to argue with you about."

Maeve looked at Iona. Iona looked back with the expression of a woman who had already lost this argument and had decided to lose it in company.

"Go on."

"The market's business depends on nobody talking to each other," Aoife said. "Every single woman in this binder went alone. That's the mechanism — not the booth, not the Ledger, the *loneliness*. If two hundred women know there are two hundred women, the whole thing starts to look like what it is." She turned a page. "So we don't raid the gate. We stand outside it and read the names out loud, and I film it, and we don't stop."

"That's a nice thought."

"It's a plan."

"It's a nice thought with a livestream attached, which makes it a nice thought that gets you killed." Maeve pulled the binder back, flattening her palm on the page. "You don't know what you're dealing with."

"I know better than you do," Aoife said, and it landed harder than she probably meant it to. "You forget I met them. The ones who come out. I've been sitting in that café on Capel Street for two years watching women come out of that gate at dusk and walk past my window like they've been hollowed. You've been chasing one woman. I've been watching all of them."

The room went quiet. Maeve's mobile lay face-down on the table where it had been since the market, unopened, the battery now flat. She picked it up, turned it over, and put it back down.

"Say it works," she said. "Say we stand at the gate and read names and Aoife streams it. What's stopping the Ledger from simply taking the phone, taking the footage, taking Aoife, and going back to business?"

"Nothing," Iona said. "Except that it never does anything in front of a crowd. Every single account in that binder has one thing in common — the woman was alone when it happened. Church on a weekday. The park at dusk. A doorway with nobody in it."

Maeve thought about the market. About the queue. About the way the trader had looked down the line, and how every woman in it had looked at her shoes. The market ran on women who couldn't say out loud what they'd done.

"Fine," she said. "But not the gate."

Aoife's head came up. "Why not?"

"Because the gate's in a park, and the park's got one road in and one road out, and if it goes wrong we're standing in the dark with our backs to a wall and a two-hundred-year-old thing that takes memories." Maeve pulled the bus map out of her jacket and spread it flat next to the binder, weighing the corners with the mug and the chip bag. "The market has two doors that we know of. Iona's bus route runs past both. But there's a third way in and out that isn't a gate at all."

She tapped the map. The canal.

"Every account in that binder has someone walking home after. Where do they walk *to*?"

Iona turned pages fast, checking. "Grand Canal Dock. The lock. Charlemont." She stopped. "They come out by the canal."

"The market sits under the waterline. The gate's the front door and the rail line's the back, and both of those belong to them." Maeve put her finger on the stretch of towpath between the two bridges, where the canal ran shallow and wide and public, with a Green and a Luas stop and a hundred windows looking down on it from the flats. "But the *surface* of the canal belongs to the city. Nobody signed anything for that. If the market's running under that stretch of water, then the water is the one threshold it doesn't control."

Aoife was already typing. "There's a plaza at the dock. Council-owned. We'd need a permit for anything with a speaker, but if we're just standing—"

"We're just standing. Reading names. Holding photographs." Maeve looked at the two of them, and felt the flat hollow thing in her chest where her father's leaving used to be, and did not let it show. "Aoife, if you stream it, can you make sure it stays up? Not just live — the recording."

"I can put it on three platforms and mirror it to a drive in Reykjavik if you want."

"I want."

"And I'll read," Iona said, quietly, one palm flat on the notebook. "I'm not going to stand there and let you do it. Brigid's names. Brigid's mother's names. I'll read the ones nobody else can pronounce."

"Then we do it Friday. Seven, when the lights come on and there's foot traffic off the Luas." Maeve was already making a list on the back of an old invoice. "We read for one hour. Names, ages, dates, and one line each about who they were before. No accusations. Nothing about the market. Nothing they can hold up in front of a judge, because we are not giving them a single word they can use."

Aoife looked up from the laptop. "Maeve. If this works, there'll be a lot of people watching."

"Good."

"If it works, they'll be watching *you*."

Maeve reached into her pocket and set the black spent button down on the table between the chip bag and the bus map, where they could all see it.

"Then let them."

Aoife held her gaze for a second, then turned the laptop round to face her.

"Friday, seven," she said, and hit the button that started the countdown.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 43: The Gathered Proof · The Market of Borrowed Names · Lumen Reads