The Painted Lie

Chapter 20: The Recruiter

Michele followed Lorenzo down the alley before first light, hood pulled low, the Bargello's notice still fresh in his mind—two men in guards' livery, one with blood on the sleeve. This morning he had burned the tunic in the studio hearth and scrubbed his hands until the skin stung. Lorenzo had watched him do it without a word, which was its own kind of answer.

Now they crossed the Ponte Santa Trinita while the water ran grey beneath them and the vendors were only just setting up their stalls. Michele kept his gaze down. Every guard's face at every corner looked like it might be holding a description.

"Where are you taking me?" he asked.

"To people who will not sell you," Lorenzo said. "That is what I promised. Nothing more until you have met them."

"You promised more than that."

Lorenzo didn't answer. He turned off the bridge and wound them through streets Michele knew only by repute—the lanes behind Santa Maria Novella, where the cloth merchants' money bought silence and the doors were thick. At a house with a plain facade and a shuttered workshop at its base, Lorenzo knocked twice and once.

A servant opened. No questions. They were led up a narrow stair into a long room hung with Flemish tapestries, and Michele understood at once that he had walked into wealth of a kind he had never stood inside before.

There were five of them waiting, seated around a table strewn with letters and a map. The youngest was perhaps thirty and wore a lawyer's plain gown. A grey-bearded man in physician's black had his hands folded. A gaunt fellow with ink-stained fingers might have been a printer. And at the head of the table, a woman with silver in her dark hair and a string of small pearls at her throat—a noblewoman, unmistakably, though she wore no rings and her sleeves were plain wool.

"Michele," Lorenzo said, "this is the Contessa Beatrice de' Rossi. The others, in their own time."

The Contessa looked at him the way a physician looks at a wound—impersonal, thorough. "You are the painter," she said. Not a question.

"I am."

"Lorenzo tells me you have a true eye and a steady hand." She gestured at a chair. "Sit. You have been carrying the reward notice around in your stomach all morning. Here you may set it down."

Michele sat. He did not set anything down.

The lawyer spoke first. "We know about Alessandro. We know he is alive and where he is not. That is enough for now." He slid a folded paper across the table. "What we do not have is a way to move him, or a way to keep him fed quietly for a season. Bribes have become expensive."

"Everything has become expensive since the Cardinal came south," the grey-beard said.

The Contessa raised a hand and they stopped. She watched Michele. "Do you know what your friend was carrying when they took him?"

Michele thought of the Basel book, the commentary calling the Donation a forgery. He looked at Lorenzo, who gave him nothing back.

"I know only that he reads things Rome would burn," Michele said carefully.

"That is a delicate way of putting it." The Contessa almost smiled. "We are all delicate here. That is the point of the room." She drew a fresh sheet from the pile and turned it so he could see. "Lorenzo says you can copy a face from memory. Is that boast or truth?"

"Truth."

"Then I have work for you."

She set before him not a portrait but a bundle of small drawings—studies of a man's face from several angles, done in a rougher hand than Michele's. A round face, wide-set eyes, a mole above the left eyebrow, a broken nose that had mended crooked.

"His name is Guido Falconieri," she said. "A professor of law from Pisa who spoke too freely in a pulpit in Lucca. He is in the Bargello now under a name that is not his, and there is a clerk who can be persuaded to help him out a postern gate—if the clerk believes he is releasing the man his warrant describes. The warrant describes Falconieri." She tapped the drawings. "But the man the guard has been told to expect does not have a broken nose, because the man who wrote the warrant does not know about it."

Michele looked at the sketches. "You want me to paint a different man. One who never existed, so that when they open a cell and find him, they will say—this is not our prisoner, the prisoner we hold has no broken nose."

"I want you to paint a portrait of the man we intend to put *in* the cell," she said evenly. "A likeness that will be shown as a warrant image. Older. Heavier in the jaw. The mole on the right, not the left. If the guard finds him a stranger to the drawing, he will be confused, and confusion is time, and time is the corridor, and the corridor is the gate."

Michele's mouth was dry. "You want me to forge a prisoner."

"I want you to paint a lie that saves a life. Yes."

The word *forge* sat in the room and nobody moved. The printer studied his inkstained hands. The lawyer watched Michele closely, as if cataloguing the exact moment a man chose.

Then Lorenzo said, quietly, "Michele."

That was all. Not a defense, not an explanation of the chest, not a word about the kiss or the lie that he had fed the Cardinal. Just his name, offered like a key, and the room waited.

Michele thought of the studio he had left, the locked iron chest with its new hasp, and the way Lorenzo's hands had been when he said *afterward*. He thought of Alessandro stitched and burning with fever above a dyer's shop, of a lantern on a stair in the dark.

And he thought of himself, a painter with a broken reputation and no workshop of his own, being asked to put his brush to a use no teacher had ever named.

"I need a good lamp," he said at last. "And the drawings for longer than an afternoon. If I am to move the mole and break the nose to the other side, I must know how the light fell when the sketches were made, or the seam will show."

The Contessa let out a breath that had been held longer than anyone had noticed. "You will have both. And a room no one watches."

"One more thing," Michele said. "The man I paint—the false one, the one who goes into the cell—what happens to him?"

The lawyer answered. "He is our own. He will be arrested under the false description and released when we pay the clerk a second time, three days after. Everyone is paid twice. That is how it survives."

"And the real Falconieri?"

"Out through the postern, over the wall to the Oltrarno, hidden in the dyer's yard with your friend until the roads open." The Contessa folded her hands. "The same road, the same roof. You are already in this, Master Michele. We are only telling you the shape of the house."

They talked then of timings and names—an innkeeper on the road to Siena, a friar in Fiesole who took letters, a merchant who owed the Contessa a debt he would gladly pay in secrecy. Michele listened and wrote nothing down, because the lawyer said no one wrote anything down. He found that he understood the reasoning, and that understanding it made him calmer, and that being calm frightened him a little.

When it was over and the others had gone, the Contessa alone remained. She looked at Michele and said, "Lorenzo vouched for you with his own safety. He does not do that often. Whatever you are to him, remember that he has now spent something on you that he cannot get back."

Michele glanced at the doorway where Lorenzo stood, and did not answer.

On the stairs, Lorenzo finally said, "Well?"

"You said you would answer about the chest."

"I said *afterward*." He held the door for Michele and they stepped out into the grey morning. "Afterward is not yet."

Michele let it go for a moment. Then, because the morning was cold and he was tired and the room had made him feel, for the first time in weeks, that he was standing somewhere solid—"The chest," he said. "Is it mine to know?"

"It is not a thing you will thank me for."

"Everything you give me is a thing I will not thank you for."

Lorenzo almost laughed. Then his face closed over. Across the street, at the corner where the alley met the wider way, a man in the brown habit of a preaching friar stood with a plain sack over his shoulder, watching the door they had just come out of.

Friar Tommaso did not move. He only looked, the way a man looks at a house he has already marked, and then he turned and walked slowly away toward Santa Maria Novella, and Lorenzo's hand closed hard on Michele's arm.

"He waited," Lorenzo said. "He waited for us to come out."

The Contessa's door behind them was shut, and there was no other way off the lane.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.