They worked from Béatrice Aubert's dining room because it was the only house in Paris where a photograph of the Comtesse's salon could sit on the table in plain sight without anyone pretending not to look at it.
Adele spread the print flat under the lamp. Fourteen people at the Comtesse's long table. Candles. The same silver epergne that had appeared in the inventory photographs from the rue de la Boétie. The Comtesse at the head, her hand on a wine glass, caught mid-sentence. At her right, in a dinner jacket, Émile Vasseur. On the left, thinner than her police photograph, Hélène Dufour, and beside Dufour a man whose face had taken Adele three full minutes to place because he wore no ribbon and no official air — but the nose, the heavy jaw, the particular way he held his cigarette between the second and third fingers — the Minister of Fine Arts.
Foucart stood behind her chair with his hands clasped behind his back. He had not sat down since he arrived.
"The Vicomte's valet identified him," he said. "Sauveterre crossed the room twice that evening. He remembers the minister's cigarette case because it was monogrammed and he thought it flashy. Also the man complained about the cold."
"It's a Paris dinner party in December," Adele said. "Everyone complained about the cold."
"Which is why I wanted a second identification." Foucart tapped the corner of the print. "Gaston. The Comtesse's own driver. He chauffeured the minister home at one in the morning and drove him again three weeks later to the same address, only the address that time was a flat on the avenue de Wagram where Dufour was keeping the Ledoux pastel before it moved."
Lucien, who had been standing at the window with his back to them, turned around. "Then you have him."
"I have a photograph. I have a driver. I have a valet who was sixty feet away and looking at a cigarette case." Foucart's mouth did the thing it did when he was about to be honest. "I don't have the minister. Do you know what happens when a commissaire walks into the Ministry of Fine Arts and says the minister was at a dinner with a known receiver of stolen goods? By the time I reach the second floor, the photograph is a forgery, the driver is a drunk, and I'm reassigned to counting bicycles in the Bois."
"So we don't walk in the front door," Adele said.
Foucart looked at her. "You have an idea."
She did. She had had it since the moment she identified the jaw, and she had spent the intervening hour deciding whether she was the kind of person who used it. The answer, she had found, sitting in that dining room with twenty-eight canvases accounted for and six restorers still ruined, was that she was.
"Print six copies," she said. "Not of the whole photograph. Of him."
Foucart's eyebrows went up.
"Six copies," Adele said, "one for the examining magistrate, one for the Préfecture, one for the Ministry of Justice, one for the Comtesse's dossier, and two for the newspapers. La Chronique des Arts will run it because they've been running everything else and they hate him. The second one we hold."
"Sauveterre will never agree," Lucien said. "He took two years to sign a deposition. If we put his name behind a newspaper photograph of a sitting minister—"
"His name isn't on it. His driver's memory is, and Gaston will stand behind a number that doesn't name him. I asked." Adele slid the print toward Foucart. "The point isn't the photograph. The point is that six copies exist. The moment a journalist is holding one, the minister has to move first. He can't have us arrested. He can't have the print destroyed. He has to call for an investigation and hope it points somewhere else."
Foucart was quiet for a moment. Then he said, "He'll resign for 'health reasons.'"
"Let him. A resignation at the Ministry is a confession with better tailoring." Adele tapped her own name, which she had written in pencil on the back. "And when the inquiry opens, it opens on Dufour. She's the only name in the ledger that hasn't spoken yet. A minister under inquiry can't protect an intermediary he wants to forget. She'll come out of wherever she's gone to ground, or she'll be found, and either way she'll talk to save herself."
"Or she'll be found dead," Lucien said.
The room went still. Adele had not let herself say it, and now that he had, she found he was right and she had been avoiding it.
"Then she's found dead," Foucart said grimly, "and we'll be able to say the ring kills its own, which is the one thing a jury never forgets."
They built it over two days. The examining magistrate, a man named Delaunay who had been dragging his feet for a month, took the print and the identification affidavits and read them twice in silence, and then asked his clerk to cancel the afternoon. The Préfecture accepted its copy through channels Foucart called "the polite fiction." The Ministry of Justice copy went in by registered post with a covering note from Béatrice Aubert's solicitor, which was the part Adele was proudest of, because a widow's registered post is a thing no clerk dares to lose.
The newspaper copy went to Étienne Rolland at La Chronique des Arts on the Thursday afternoon. Rolland, who had covered the Salle Gaveau concert, read the caption Adele had drafted — "A dinner at the rue de la Boétie, December 1924" — and looked up at her.
"You understand I'll have to verify this before I print it."
"Verify it however you like. It'll take you a week. Everyone who's ever been to that house is verifying it right now, because I sent the other five copies on the same day." Adele set her gloves back on. "You'll be beaten to it by a magistrate, which I think you'll enjoy."
He printed the photograph on Saturday. By Sunday the minister had announced a full inquiry into "irregularities in the movement of privately held works." By Monday he had announced his retirement. By Tuesday, Hélène Dufour had been taken into custody at a lodging in Versailles, where she had been living under her sister's name since January and, according to Foucart, starting every morning with a telephone call to a number that no longer answered.
Adele heard about the arrest from Foucart at her new studio, which was not yet a studio: two rooms on the rue de Seine, still smelling of plaster, with Marguerite's easel already in the corner because Marguerite had arrived with it on the first day and announced that a room without an easel was an insult. The windows needed cleaning. The light was extraordinary.
"She asked for a lawyer the moment we put her in the car," Foucart said, standing in the doorway because there was nowhere yet to sit. "Then she asked for the Comtesse. When we told her, she started to cry."
"Grief?"
"Calculation. It took her about four minutes to decide that everything in that ledger was the Comtesse's idea and the Comtesse was dead, which I imagine is the safest thing a living woman can say." He took out his notebook, opened it, closed it again. "She'll testify. She wants immunity and she'll get a reduced charge instead. But she'll testify."
"Against whom?"
"Against everyone she can see from where she's sitting. That's the thing about intermediaries. They only ever meet the middle." Foucart put the notebook away. "She's going to name the Comtesse first, then Vasseur, then the minister. She'll name eleven restorers before she names a single dealer who's still alive. But she'll name the Comtesse, in open court, and that's what the case has needed since the first canvas came off that wall."
Adele stood very still. Behind her, in the corner, Marguerite had stopped pretending not to listen and set down her brush.
"Open court," Adele said.
"The trial's set for the autumn. She'll be charged in absentia or they'll postpone for the estate, but the trial happens, and there's a witness list." Foucart looked at her steadily. "Your name is on it. So is his. And, mademoiselle—" he said, and the formality made her stomach drop, because he only used it when he was about to hand her something heavy, "—the examining magistrate is asking for the microfilm. Not a transcript. The film. To be produced as evidence, sealed, and kept in the court's possession."
The ledger transcripts were paper. The microfilm was the original, and it was in the tin in her satchel, and it was the only thing in Paris that could prove the truth of every line Marguerite had copied out by hand.
"Once it's sealed," Lucien said from the hallway, where he had been carrying in a chair and had stopped, "we can't use it. Not for the French owners, not for the Belgian ones. Everyone who hasn't already testified becomes a loose end."
"I know," Adele said.
She looked at the two rooms, the plaster, the easel, the light she had not yet earned. Then she went to her satchel, took out the tin, and set it on the windowsill, in the daylight, where the whole street could see it if the whole street cared to look.
"Then we have until autumn," she said, "to find every owner on that list before the court takes the only proof we have."