The Scent of Our Own

Chapter 54: Manon's Testimony

The courtroom smelled of dust, floor wax, and the particular staleness of a room where the heating had been on too long. Céline had been here four hours. She had learned the grain of the bench in front of her, the exact frequency of Alexandre's chair creaking, the way the clerk's pen scratched without rhythm.

"Maître Dupont, your next witness."

Manon rose from the second row. She had worn grey wool — no couture flourish, no brooch, nothing that invited the eye to judge her body instead of her words. A tailored jacket, a plain silk blouse, her hair pinned low. Céline recognized the strategy because she had watched Manon build it in the studio mirror at six that morning. Dress like the room. Then take the room.

Manon crossed to the witness box. The clerk administered the oath. She said *je le jure* in a voice that carried to the back wall.

Dupont straightened his cuffs. "Madame Sauvage, you are the co-founder of Maison Rousseau-Sauvage. Is that correct?"

"It is."

"And before that?"

"I spent eleven years in Paris ateliers. Four at Maison Lumière, in the première's workroom. Before that, two other houses. I trained at the École in Lyon."

"You are an Omega. Correct?"

"I am."

"Were you ever asked to disclose your designation at hiring?"

Manon's hands stayed folded on the rail. "Every single time. Even when the form did not ask. It came up in the interview. In the third house I was told to submit to a scent questionnaire — an informal one, no medical body, no consent form — so the management could be sure I would not disturb the workroom."

"Disturb how?"

"Because of heats, Maître. Because of the smell of an Omega under stress. Because of the idea that we are an inconvenience to the productivity of Alphas in proximity to us."

A murmur ran along the benches. The judge, a woman in her fifties with reading glasses pushed up into her hair, wrote something.

Alexandre's counsel, Maître Benoît, leaned back and folded his arms. He would object soon. Manon did not look at him.

"And at Maison Lumière specifically," Dupont said. "What was your designation status there?"

"It was known. It was not written in the file. Monsieur Bertin preferred that certain things not be documented. He said it kept things 'flexible.'"

"What did 'flexible' mean in practice?"

"It meant that when a designer needed a scented sample, I was handed the vials. When the accounts needed an extra set of hands at two in the morning, I was called. When the season ended, my contract was not renewed — because a client's wife had complained that an Omega had fitted her bodice."

"Objection." Benoît was on his feet. "Relevance. We are here to determine authorship of a formula, not the general conditions of an atelier."

The judge looked at him over the glasses. "Maître, the witness has been asked to establish the working conditions in which the formula was allegedly created. I will allow it."

"I will rephrase," Dupont said mildly. "Madame Sauvage, in your time at Maison Lumière, did you see Céline Rousseau work on a fragrance composition?"

"Every day. For four years."

"Can you describe what you saw?"

"She was given a corner of the lab nobody else wanted — it backed onto a radiator, the temperature was unstable, and the light was wrong. She was told to develop what Monsieur Bertin called 'Omega work' — the intimate, skin-adjacent formulas. The idea being, I suppose, that an Omega would have a natural feeling for the kind of scent that lived close to the body."

"Was that a compliment?"

Manon almost smiled. "It was a division of labour. The Alpha noses were given the grand houses, the big commissions. The Omega noses were given the base layer. The parts you do not put a name on the box."

"And who put their name on the box?"

"Maison Lumière. And on the bottle, Monsieur Bertin's signature. Not hers. Never hers."

Céline's hands were cold. She kept them still on her knees. Across the aisle she could feel Alexandre's attention like a weight, and she did not turn to meet it.

Dupont lifted a document. "I show you a copy of the Rousseau family's employment records from Maison Lumière, entries from the relevant months. Do you recognize these?"

"Yes. The Omega staff are listed in a separate annex. Not in the main payroll. Paid through a subcontractor — a bureau de mise à disposition."

"Why would a house use a subcontractor for its own permanent staff?"

"So the head count would not show them as our employees. So if anything went wrong — a complaint, a claim, a theft — the house could say they were not working for the house."

Benoît objected again. The judge overruled him. He sat back down, and his pen moved fast.

Dupont walked her through the day the formula left the atelier. Manon described the courier log, the sealed envelope, the wrongness of the schedule — Bertin requesting the base formulas "for archiving" on a day the archive room was closed for fumigation. She described the sealed envelopes delivered to the wrong floor. She described finding Céline in the stairwell afterwards, hands shaking.

"Did you see Céline Rousseau's notebooks?"

"Every day. I bound them for her. I made the covers by hand so she would not be embarrassed to carry them in the corridors. The Alpha staff had embossed editions. She had mine."

"Objection —" Benoît began.

"Overruled."

"Madame Sauvage," Dupont said, "you are a designer. You have a professional interest in who signs what. In your judgement, is it possible that the formula at issue was developed by anyone other than Céline Rousseau?"

"No." Manon's voice did not rise. "It is not possible. I watched the first drafts. I watched the corrections. I watched her take out an accord of orris because Monsieur Bertin said it was 'too fine for a base.' She put it back the next day, because she knew it belonged. That is authorship. It is not a signature. It is the stubbornness of one person over time. Monsieur Bertin does not have that relationship with any accord."

The courtroom was quiet. The clerk's pen had stopped.

Benoît rose for cross. He took his time walking to the lectern, arranging his papers, letting the silence work for him.

"Madame Sauvage. You are the co-founder of the house now in competition with my client's. You have — let me be precise — a direct financial interest in this court finding for the plaintiff. Correct?"

"Correct. Much as my client's accuser has a direct financial interest in the opposite."

He glanced up sharply. A ripple of amusement passed through the press bench. He did not like it.

"In your eleven years of ateliers, were you ever disciplined?"

"Never."

"Were you ever dismissed?"

"Not renewed. Four times. Always at the end of a season. Always an Omega, always the Omega."

"So you have a grievance."

"I have a history. There is a difference."

He tried her on dates. On the exact wording of the courier log. On whether she could be sure which envelope contained the sealed formula. Manon answered each one without hurry, without heat, correcting him where his dates were wrong and conceding where they were right. She conceded twice. It made her stronger, not weaker. Céline saw the judge's pen move both times.

Benoît changed angle. "You believe the industry is biased against Omegas."

"I do not believe it. I have documented it. There are twelve of us who are willing to say so, and we have the subcontracts to prove the pattern. We are filing separately."

That landed. The clerk wrote. Benoît's mouth tightened. He had not expected a second action. Céline had not known about the twelve either — Manon had kept that in reserve, and Céline felt a small, private flare of pride at the discipline of it.

"No further questions," Benoît said, and sat down.

The judge looked at Manon over her glasses. "Madame Sauvage, one point from the bench. You said the house's records separated Omega staff. In your knowledge, was this also true at Maison Lumière's competitor houses?"

"It was standard practice. It still is, in some."

"Thank you. You may step down."

Manon stepped down. She passed Céline's row and did not look at her, which was the right thing, and Céline watched her regain her seat with an even gait, and put her hands in her lap, and keep her face still.

Alexandre was staring at Manon. From across the aisle, Céline could see the muscle working at the hinge of his jaw. He leaned to Benoît and said something short. Benoît shook his head once, and Alexandre's glare turned on him instead. Then, as if feeling the weight of being watched, he turned and found Céline.

She did not drop her gaze. She held it — not long, not theatrically, just long enough to let him know she was not going to. He looked away first. It was not a victory, exactly. It was a ledger entry.

The judge said, "Maître Dupont, do you have further witnesses for the afternoon?"

"One, Madame la Présidente. Hélène Petit, formerly of the Maison Lumière laboratory."

The judge nodded and looked at the clerk. "Call her."

The clerk called the name. The doors at the back of the courtroom did not open. The clerk called it again, louder.

In the third row, a man in a brown coat stood up slowly. He was a junior from Benoît's office; Céline had seen him pass notes all morning. He walked to the bar and spoke low to Benoît, who frowned, then turned and whispered to Alexandre. Alexandre's expression did not change. That was the tell. It should have changed.

Dupont rose. "Madame la Présidente, the witness has not answered the summons. I am told —" he paused, and looked at the junior, "— that Hélène Petit did not appear at the door this morning. Nor did she answer her telephone."

"Was she served?" the judge asked.

"She was served on Tuesday."

"Then I will hear from her tomorrow morning. If she has not appeared by ten, counsel will explain to me why." The judge's glasses came down. "Court is adjourned until ten."

The gavel. The room stood. Céline stayed seated a moment, watching Alexandre walk out through the side door without once looking back at the gallery, and understanding — with the cold, clean logic of a nose reading a formula — that the fact that Hélène Petit had not come today meant she had already been got to, or she had already gone, and the second was worse.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.