The Unbinding

Chapter 28: Claire's Second Visit

The Hoboken brownstone looked different in daylight. The last time they'd stood on this stoop, rain had sheened the steps and Claire had let them in like a woman expecting a reckoning. Now the afternoon was bright and flat, and the difference made the damage harder to see at first.

Claire opened the door before they knocked. She'd been watching the street.

"Inside. Quickly." She pulled them through, shut the door, threw the deadbolt, then the chain. Her hands were steady, which was somehow worse than shaking.

The apartment looked the same, then didn't. Benjamin had catalogued it on the first visit the way he catalogued everything: the shelf of old paperbacks, the desk with its salvage-pile of unpaid bills, the tea tin. Now the books had been pulled half-off the shelf and left to lean crooked. The desk drawer hung open, its contents fanned across the floor.

"They took the papers," Claire said. "Grandmother's. Every box, every folder. I came home Tuesday and the door was open and the locks weren't broken and they were just - gone."

"The lock picks," Nicolas said. "Professional."

"Or a key." Claire crossed to the kitchen and didn't offer them anything. She just stood with her back to the counter, arms folded. "Here's what I want to know. I've had those papers in this apartment for four years. Nobody cared. Then you two show up asking about Edith and Margaret and a boy lost in 1994, and two weeks later someone walks in and takes the whole archive." She looked at Nicolas. "So who did you tell?"

"Nobody."

"You told your buyer."

Nicolas went still. Benjamin watched the accusation land and saw the exact moment Nicolas decided to be honest, which was new.

"Almost nobody," Nicolas said. "There's a broker. Hélène Fauré. She knows I was looking at the Matheson estate. She doesn't know about Claire or this address."

"Almost nobody is a whole lot of nobody," Claire said.

Benjamin stepped in. "Claire. If they were professionals and they took everything, that's actually good news for you and bad news for us. It means whoever is buying up Edith's estate wanted your grandmother's copy of it off the board. It doesn't mean they know about you."

"The chain got thrown, not just the lock," Claire said. "That's not a message. That's a warning."

"It's both," Benjamin said quietly.

She held his eye for a long moment, then exhaled and walked past them into the bedroom. They heard her moving something heavy. When she came back she was carrying a flat brown envelope, soft at the corners, held against her body with both arms like a shield.

"They took the boxes," she said. "They didn't take the one thing I didn't put in the boxes."

She laid the envelope on the kitchen table. Inside was a single sheet of paper, older than the rest, a brittle rectangle torn from something bound. The blue ink had faded to the color of veins under skin.

"My grandmother kept this separate," Claire said. "She told me once, when I was small, that if anyone ever came asking about Margaret Ellery, this was the only page that mattered. I didn't know what she meant until you called. I didn't know what she meant until this week."

Benjamin put on his cotton gloves from his jacket pocket without thinking - Claire noticed, and for the first time something in her face loosened. He flattened the page under the lamp and read it aloud, slowly, because the handwriting was cramped and the paper wanted to fold on its old creases.

November 3, 1994. Margaret's hand, mid-slope, pressing hard.

*Edith came tonight with the papers and the boys' file. She is worse than I thought. She says it must be now or not at all, that after the 3rd the house is watched and the arrangements will be missed. I said I would take them both. I meant it. A house with one boy is a house with a hostage; a house with two is a family, and I could have raised them better than this. Edith refused. She said only one could go. She said the older boy was damaged, that he'd seen too much at the dinner and would tell it eventually, and that if I took both she would not protect me. She stood in my doorway and made me choose in under a minute. I have never been so ashamed of anything. I took the little one. God forgive me, I took the little one and I let her take the other away, and I have not slept since.*

Benjamin finished and the kitchen was absolutely silent. The refrigerator hummed. Somewhere down the block a car alarm gave one confused chirp and stopped.

Nicolas had gone pale in a way Benjamin had seen once before, on the train, when he'd described his father putting him in a stranger's car. This was the same color, but worse, because this time he wasn't remembering. He was finding out.

"Read the last line again," Nicolas said. His voice came out level and strange.

Benjamin did.

"I took the little one."

"That's me." Nicolas said it like he was identifying a body. "I'm the little one. Julian was - " He stopped. Started again. "Julian was *older*. Three years. I always knew he was three years older. And she - " He turned away from the table, walked two steps, came back. "She took me. Edith *gave* me away. To strangers, to a car in the middle of the night, that was *her*. She's the one who put me in that car."

"She thought she was saving you," Claire said, tentatively.

"No." Nicolas was not shouting, which was worse. "She thought she was saving *herself*. She took both of us out of that house and then she split us so that neither of us would ever tell it together. Two six-year-olds, one story. Split the story, you split the evidence." He pressed the heels of his hands against his eyes. "I've been looking for my brother for twenty years. I've been *hunting* my brother like he was a missing item in an auction lot, and the whole time the person who hired me, who picked me, who put me in this room - "

"She did pick you," Benjamin said. "That's the part that scares me now."

Nicolas dropped his hands and looked at him. Benjamin went on, fast, because if he slowed down he'd feel the weight of it.

"Edith chose to separate you. Edith chose to hide Julian. And according to everything we have, Edith is dead. Which means either she's alive, using Margaret's trust and Margaret's name - or she left someone a set of instructions, and that someone has been following them for years. Either way, the person who is buying up her estate knows she did this. The person who burglarized this apartment knows she did this."

Claire had gone still. "What are you saying."

"I'm saying the thing they took this week isn't the same as the thing they wanted. They took the boxes because they're clearing the record. But this page - " Benjamin touched the edge of the paper. "This page is the proof that a crime was committed. Not a disappearance. A deliberate, planned *separation*, carried out by an adult who then arranged for both children to have no memory of each other."

"I have memories," Nicolas said quietly. "They're just under everything else. I remembered the car. I remembered my father's hands on my shoulders. I didn't remember a brother until Burlington, and I still don't - I don't *have* him. I have the shape of a missing thing." He put his hand flat on the table beside the diary page, not quite touching it. "She took that from me on purpose. That's the part. She didn't lose Julian. She *filed* him."

Claire sat down slowly, as if the chair might not hold her either. "So what do we do."

Benjamin looked at Nicolas. Nicolas was breathing hard through his nose, staring at the page, and Benjamin could see him building something out of the grief - a structure, a next step, a target.

"We don't leave this page here," Benjamin said. "We photograph it, we take the photos and a transcription, and the original goes somewhere that isn't this apartment."

"I have a safe deposit box," Claire said. "It can go there tonight."

"Good." Benjamin folded the envelope, then stopped. "Nicolas."

"What."

"There's a name in this entry that matters more than the rest. She says Edith came *with* the boys' file. A file. Edith had a file on you both before she ever gave you away. That means there was documentation - birth records, placement paperwork, something that predates the night. Someone has had a file on you and your brother since before you can remember." He caught Nicolas's eyes and held them. "That file still exists. It has to. And the person who has it is the person who engineered all of this from the beginning. Your file is the key. And so is Julian's."

Nicolas looked at the page for a long moment. Then he reached out and, carefully, folded it back into its envelope, and put it in Claire's hands.

"Then we're not going to Montreal as bait anymore," he said. "We're going there as a *demand*."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 28: Claire's Second Visit · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads