The Unbinding

Chapter 29: The Choice Edith Made

The diary was small, a drugstore notebook with a cracked spine, and Claire had wrapped it in a dish towel like something that might burn her. Benjamin turned the pages on the kitchen table while Nicolas stood behind him, not sitting, not pacing, just standing with his hands on the back of the chair.

Margaret's handwriting was a tight, furious scrawl, dated entries crammed into whatever white space she could find. Most of it was numbers. Suspected losses. Names of donors crossed out. The paranoia of a woman who had built something and watched it come apart.

Then, September 1994.

*The car is handled. E. saw to the rest. I was to take the boys but I could only manage the one. The little one is adoptable—clean, no memories worth keeping, he'll go to a family, real family, not this. The older one is damaged. He saw too much and he'll never stop looking. I told them Julian could not be placed and they took him somewhere I am not supposed to know about. It is the only way to keep them apart. If they are ever in the same room again, everything we did comes back.*

Benjamin read it twice before he understood what he was reading. He looked up.

Nicolas's face had gone flat and still, the way it went when he was doing arithmetic he didn't want to finish. "Read the last part again."

"You don't want—"

"Read it."

Benjamin read it. *If they are ever in the same room again, everything we did comes back.*

Nicolas let go of the chair. He walked to the window, which looked out on a brick wall and a fire escape, and stood there with his back to the room.

"So that's why," he said. His voice was very even. "I got picked. I got the family with the lawn and the piano lessons. He got—whatever he got. Because a stranger decided I was clean and he was damaged."

"Margaret decided that. Not you."

"Because I forgot." He turned around. "That's what she means by clean, isn't it? No memories worth keeping. I was six years old and I forgot my own parents, and that's why the Ashfords wanted me. I forgot, and Julian didn't, and he's been paying for it for thirty years."

"That's not—"

"Don't." He held up a hand. "Don't do the thing where you tell me it's not my fault. I know it's not my fault. That's not what this is." He pressed the heel of his hand against his eye. "When they put me in the car, my father said *don't look for us.* I spent two years thinking he meant don't look back. Move on. Be good. And I did. I was so good. So quiet. I learned to be whatever the room wanted, and it worked, and they kept me."

"Nicolas."

"He hid one of us. She hid one of us. They kept us apart on purpose, and I made it easy, because I was the easy one." His hand dropped. "I've been hunting a man for twenty years and the whole time he was the one who got left behind."

Claire had retreated to the doorway. She said, quietly, "I didn't know. I swear to you. My grandmother never told me any of this. When I found the diary I thought it was just—old guilt. Money guilt. I didn't understand until I read the last page and I called you."

Benjamin closed the notebook. He stood up.

He was not a man who touched people. It was in the architecture of him—the careful distance at auction previews, the handshake that ended at the wrist, the reason his only long relationship had ended with *you're always somewhere else.* It had been years since he'd initiated anything with anyone. Some part of him filed physical contact in the same drawer as the fragile bindings at work: beautiful, verboten, handle only with gloves.

He crossed the kitchen and put his arms around Nicolas.

Nicolas went rigid. Then he shuddered and his forehead came down on Benjamin's shoulder, and Benjamin held him there, one hand flat between his shoulder blades, and felt the man's breath come apart.

"You were six years old," Benjamin said, into his hair. "You were six years old and a grown woman looked at two orphaned children and decided the convenience of the one was worth the disappearance of the other. That's not your sin. That's hers. You don't get to carry it because she's dead and can't."

"I should have looked."

"You did look. You looked for thirty years and you found me looking at the same question from the other side." His hand moved once, a small useless gesture of soothing. "That's not nothing. That might be the whole point. Someone wanted us in the same room, and here we are, and they're going to regret it."

Nicolas laughed, wet and broken, against his collar. Neither of them moved for a while. The radiator ticked. Somewhere in the building a door slammed.

Then Nicolas pulled back enough to look at him, close, wary, his eyes red. "Does that offer have an expiration."

"What offer."

"Staying." He tipped his head toward the window, the dark brick, the endless city on the other side of it. "I don't want to be alone in this apartment tonight. I've been alone in this apartment every night for eleven years and I just found out the exact reason for it and I don't think I can—"

"Yes," Benjamin said.

Nicolas blinked. "I wasn't finished."

"You don't have to finish."

"Your place is across town."

"I know where my place is."

Nicolas looked at him for a long second. Some of the flatness left his face, replaced by something more dangerous, something that had been standing in the wings for weeks. "The couch is terrible," he said.

"I've slept on worse."

"I only have the one blanket."

Benjamin almost smiled. "Then we'll have to share it."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.