Benjamin woke because the light had changed. Not the blue flicker of the city through the blinds, but a flat, pearled gray, the color of morning with no sun in it. New York in October had two moods and this was the second one: a low ceiling of cloud that made everything indoors feel warmer than it was.
He was on Nicolas's couch under a blanket that smelled faintly of cedar. He had not slept in his clothes in years, not since grad school, and his shirt had twisted itself into a knot across his ribs sometime in the night. His mouth tasted like the coffee they'd had at ten and nothing since.
The apartment was quiet in the way of a place that had been quiet a long time. He sat up slowly. The room hadn't changed except that yesterday's exhaustion had drained out of it. Two walls of bookshelves. A Turkish lamp that looked old enough to be real. On the low table, the sketchbook — Edith's sketchbook, if it was hers — lay closed under a sheet of glass Benjamin had cut himself from a scrap in the back of a cabinet, an old conservator's habit he hadn't thought about until his hands were already doing it.
Down the hall, water ran, and stopped.
Nicolas came out in a T-shirt that was too big for him and a pair of gray sweatpants, bare feet, his hair still flattened on one side from the pillow. No cufflinks, no watch. He was holding two mugs and he stopped when he saw Benjamin awake, and something passed over his face that Benjamin couldn't name — not surprise. Relief, maybe, quickly put away.
"You're still here."
"You said stay."
"I say a lot of things." Nicolas handed him a mug and sat at the other end of the couch, one leg folded under him. "It's terrible coffee. I only have the one mug that matches."
Benjamin drank. It was terrible. "It's fine."
"It's not."
"It's fine."
Nicolas laughed — a short, low sound, almost to himself — and drank from his mug, and for a minute neither of them said anything. The radiator ticked. Somewhere out on the street a truck downshifted and the whole window rattled in its frame.
Benjamin looked at him sideways, at the collarbone showing above the stretched neck of the shirt, at the two days of stubble, at the small bald patch in the eyebrow — the left one, he'd noticed it in the archive under fluorescent light and hadn't known what to do with the noticing. He'd spent his whole adult life being careful. Careful was a wall with his own name on it. He had held this man last night while he came apart, and no one had told him the wall was supposed to have a door in it.
"You look about nineteen," he said.
"Thank you."
"It wasn't a compliment."
"It was a little bit." Nicolas pushed his hair back off his forehead and it fell forward again. "I feel about ninety. That's usually how these things run."
"These things."
"Coming apart on a stranger's couch at two in the morning."
"I'm not a stranger."
Nicolas looked at him over the rim of the mug, and neither of them did anything with that, which was itself a kind of answer.
"I'm a fixer," Benjamin said, after a while. "That's — you should know that about me. Not the job. The whole thing. When I was a kid I used to repair my own toys and then hide the seams. My mother would say, you can't tell you did anything at all, and I'd feel — I don't know. Praised. I once spent a summer teaching myself to hold my pencil the way the other boys did, because mine made a mark at a different angle. I was eleven."
"Eleven," Nicolas repeated.
"Eleven."
"That's a strange thing for an eleven-year-old to care about."
"Yes." Benjamin turned the mug in his hands. The glaze was cracked at the base; unglazed earthenware, older than the apartment, probably inherited. "That's the point I'm making. I was very good at making myself correct. I got good at it early and I never really stopped. Every book in my studio is finished. Every tool in its place. I can't leave a room until everything's square." He paused. "And I've spent the last month in your life, which is the least square thing I have ever been near, and I keep coming back."
Nicolas set his mug down and didn't look away. "That's almost a compliment."
"It's a diagnosis."
"Same thing, in my family." He said it lightly and then heard himself, and the lightness went out of it. His jaw worked once. He pulled the blanket up over his knee, a small defensive motion, almost unconscious.
Benjamin didn't ask. He'd learned that much by now — that Nicolas answered faster to silence than to a question.
"I was a different person in every house," Nicolas said finally. "That's the honest version. After — after the placement, I mean. There was a couple in Westchester, there was a school, there was a family in Vermont I was with for nearly two years. I built a boy for each of them. The Westchester boy did lacrosse. The Vermont boy read French novels and played piano by ear. None of them lied, exactly. I could do all of it. I just couldn't tell you which one was me when I was alone in the room."
"What did the alone version do?"
"Listened at doors," Nicolas said. "That was the only consistent part. My whole childhood was a stakeout. I'd hear things through walls and put them together in my head and never, ever say what I'd heard. That's where I learned to keep people two rooms away." He gave a small, dry smile. "It also means I'm very good at my job."
"Which one's the real one?"
"Right now?" Nicolas looked at him steadily. "This one is closer than any of them has been in a long time. Which is inconvenient."
"Why inconvenient?"
"Because it means it can be taken away."
Benjamin had no answer for that, so he did what he did with damaged paper: he sat with it, and didn't touch it, and let it be what it was. The radiator ticked. A gull crossed the gray window and was gone.
"You want toast?" Nicolas said. "I have bread. It's not a date, it's toast."
"Since you've made the distinction."
"I'm very clear on the distinction."
"Are you."
"Extremely."
Benjamin stood, and brought both mugs to the counter, and when Nicolas moved past him to pull the bread out of the bag their arms touched at the wrists and neither of them moved away. It lasted about a second and a half. It was not toast. They both knew it was not toast. Nobody said anything, which in Benjamin's experience was how the most important things got kept.
They ate standing up, leaning on opposite sides of the counter, in the easy silence of two people who had run out of the news. Nicolas tore his crust off and stacked it in a neat little pile. Benjamin noticed and said nothing about it. The sky outside was the color of a troweled-over grave and neither of them cared, this morning, what it meant.
Nicolas's phone was on the counter by the sink. It buzzed once against the stone — a short, blunt sound, one notification, no repeat.
He glanced at it the way he glanced at everything, without moving his head, and then he looked at it properly, and then he picked it up.
His face went through something fast. Not the collapse of last night — narrower than that. Set. The chameleon lights coming back on in a dark house.
Benjamin set his toast down. "Who is it?"
"Unknown number."
"Read it to me."
Nicolas hesitated half a second, which was half a second more than he would have hesitated an hour ago.
I know what you're looking for. Stop.
He turned the screen and Benjamin read it himself.
The sentence sat there in its little blue bubble, brightly, innocently, as things do when they mean to kill you.
Benjamin's first instinct was the conservator's — stabilize, document, do not touch. "Take a screenshot," he said. "Email it to yourself. Then we call someone."
"Call who."
"You know who. There's a detective in the 1994 file. There's—"
"I'm not calling anyone," Nicolas said, and his voice was flat and reasonable and completely unmovable. "I have a passport on this name that took me three years to build. I have a lease, a bank, an entire life, and none of it goes through the federal system. The moment a cop types my name into a terminal, this is over for me. They won't put me in a witness box. They'll put me in a cell and then they'll put me wherever they put the people they can't deport and can't file."
"You don't know that."
"I know it exactly."
They stood facing each other across the counter, four feet of scuffed marble, the toast cooling between them.
"So what, then," Benjamin said. "You go to Montreal right now, tonight, alone. Into whatever this is."
"I don't go alone." Nicolas held his eyes. "You come. Which I'm not sure I have any right to ask."
"You're asking."
"I'm asking."
Benjamin closed his eyes. When he opened them, the street was still gray and the coffee was still terrible and there was still a hand-thrown mug in his hand with a glaze crack at its base, and he was, apparently, going to Montreal. He thought, briefly and without any particular emotion, of the insurance paperwork still sitting on his desk at the studio, half-completed, in his even, unremarkable hand.
"One condition," he said.
"Name it."
"I tell someone where we're going. Not the police. My lawyer. If something goes wrong, someone in New York knows I'm in Canada and knows I said I'd check in."
Nicolas considered it — and for a moment Benjamin watched him try on refusing, and then, like a coat that didn't fit, take it off again. "Fine. Call him. But the purpose of the trip stays between us."
"Obviously."
"Say it."
"The purpose stays between us," Benjamin said.
He took his phone off the counter and stepped into the other room, where the light was the same flat gray, and the blinds made stripes on the floor. He dialed. It rang twice.
"Tomas, it's Ben. I need to tell you where I'll be."
His lawyer's voice was brisk and a little annoyed. "How long."
"Two days. Maybe three. Montreal."
"Work or family."
Benjamin looked back through the doorway. Nicolas had turned to look out at the street, one hand resting flat on the counter, his shoulders down, the T-shirt collar sagged over the thin bone at the base of his neck.
"Work," Benjamin said. "A private commission. On a manuscript I'd rather not describe over the phone."
"Fine. Send me the address when you have it. And Benjamin — take a scarf, it's cold up there."
"I will."
He hung up. The lie sat in him, clean and square and perfectly hidden at the seams, and he stood for a moment in the gray room before he went back to the coffee and the toast and the man in the too-big shirt, and told himself it didn't matter, and knew it did.