The Unbinding

Chapter 74: The Answer

The courthouse steps were still crowded when Nicolas asked it, and Benjamin didn't answer. The press was a wall of cameras ten feet below, and Reyes was watching them from the doorway with the flat patience of a man who'd just gotten what he came for. So Benjamin said nothing. He put his hand on Nicolas's elbow and steered him down the side stairs, through the service alley, out onto Worth Street where the light was grey and ordinary and nobody knew either of their names.

They walked. That was all. Benjamin didn't plan it; his legs just kept moving and Nicolas kept pace, and eventually the buildings thinned and they were in Foley Square with its hard granite and its rows of empty benches, the courthouse colonnade behind them looking like something that had been built to outlast everyone inside it.

Nicolas sat first. Benjamin sat beside him, close enough that their coats touched at the shoulder.

"You didn't answer me," Nicolas said.

"I know."

"It's a simple question. Your emails were clean. You could have said you suspected in March, not October, and nobody could have contradicted you. You'd be a witness with clean hands instead of a witness with a confession attached." Nicolas's voice was level in the way that cost him something. "So why."

Benjamin looked at his own hands. Restorer's hands. Steady, deliberate, ruined at the knuckles from years of scalpels and bone folders. He'd spent his whole adult life taking things apart to find out how they were made, and he'd never once turned that instrument on himself. That was the thing about being a conservator. You learned the integrity of the object. You learned where the water damage started and how far it had spread. You did not, as a rule, ask who had let it get wet.

"I thought about it," he said. "In the car, on the way to the grand jury. I had the whole thing worked out. I could have said I only suspected in December, after the dealer's letter. Nobody could have proven otherwise. My emails were ambiguous. You said so yourself."

"So why didn't you."

"Because I ran the version where I did." Benjamin kept his eyes on his hands. "I ran it all the way out. I testify clean, I walk away, you go down on the document charge because there's nobody left to say what you knew. I keep the studio. I keep the name. And then I go home to Paramus, and I sit in my mother's house, and I know."

"You know what."

"That I did it." He said it plainly. It was the only way to say it. "That when it cost me something, I chose the thing that cost me nothing. And I'd have to live in that. Every day, for the rest of my life, in a world where I'd already done it." He turned his head finally. Nicolas was looking at him with an expression Benjamin couldn't read, which was normal, which was always normal, except that this time there was something underneath it that looked almost like fear. "I didn't want to live in that world, Nicolas. So I didn't make it."

Nicolas didn't say anything for a long moment. A pigeon landed on the bench back and considered them both and left.

"That's not a legal answer," Nicolas said at last. "That's a stupid answer. That's the stupidest—" He stopped. He laughed, once, without much air behind it. "You understand that's a stupid answer. You gave up a hundred and fifty thousand dollars for me and then you stood in front of a federal prosecutor and told him the truth about it, and you're telling me now you did it so you could like yourself."

"Yes."

"Benjamin."

"It wasn't so I could like myself." Benjamin turned on the bench, one knee up, facing him. "It was so I could keep you. That's the part I couldn't say in there. If I'd walked away clean I'd have kept my name and lost the only real thing I've had since I was nine years old. And I've lost enough. I know exactly what that feels like. I could have told you what the years after that feel like, and I'd rather testify with blood on my hands than find out again."

The silence went on long enough that Benjamin heard the traffic signal on Centre Street change twice.

"Since you were nine," Nicolas said.

"Yes."

"What happened when you were nine."

"Not now."

"No." Nicolas nodded slowly. "Not now."

He was still for a second, and then he moved, and it wasn't a large motion. He turned toward Benjamin on the bench and reached up and put his hand flat against Benjamin's jaw, thumb under the cheekbone, and held him there and looked at him, searching, the way he'd looked at the provenance document the first time he ever showed up at the studio—checking for the repair, checking where the seam was. Benjamin held still under it. He had spent a year being looked at by this man and never let himself be found. He let himself be found.

"I'm going to do something," Nicolas said. "Tell me not to."

Benjamin couldn't find his voice. He shook his head, small, against the hand.

And Nicolas kissed him. On a bench in Foley Square, in the grey cold, with the courthouse full of people deciding what to do about both of them, Nicolas Ash—or whoever he was, whatever the file said, whatever name he'd be called by at the next hearing—kissed Benjamin with a carefulness that had nothing to do with doubt. His mouth was cold and then warm. His hand stayed on Benjamin's jaw like it was holding something it intended to keep.

Benjamin made a sound he didn't mean to make. He put his hand on Nicolas's coat and closed his eyes and for a minute or a year there was nothing in the world that had a case number attached to it. It was the first time in a very long time that he wasn't restoring anything. He wasn't repairing, wasn't assessing, wasn't cataloguing damage. He was just in it, in the room of it, and there was no before and no after.

Then Nicolas pulled away.

He didn't go far. Inches. His hand slid off Benjamin's jaw and fell to his own knee. But he pulled away, and when Benjamin opened his eyes there was that expression again, and now Benjamin could name it. It wasn't fear of Benjamin. It was fear of exactly this—standing on the far side of a door he'd already walked through.

"Nicolas."

"Give me a second."

"I'm not going anywhere."

"That's the problem." Nicolas laughed again, that short airless thing, and looked out at the square—the pigeons, the bare trees, the courthouse with its lights coming on floor by floor as the afternoon failed. "You said you didn't want to live in a world where you'd betrayed me. Fine. That's your answer and I accept it. But you didn't ask what happens to me in the world where you don't."

Benjamin waited.

"I paid a man a hundred thousand dollars of your money to keep him quiet," Nicolas said. "No—not your money. Your mother's book. You sold your mother's book to buy me out of a hole I dug myself, and then you stood up in front of the government and took my name off the hook with your own, and now you've just—" He stopped. His jaw worked. "I have spent twenty years making sure that nobody ever had anything on me that I couldn't afford to lose. That was the whole architecture. That was the entire design. And you've just walked in and started taking it apart with your hands, and you're doing it gently, which is worse."

"I don't want anything on you."

"That's the part I don't—" He stopped again. He looked at Benjamin and something in his face gave, just slightly, like a hinge loosening. "I don't know how to be loved," he said. "I only know how to hide. That's the only thing I was ever good at, before the books. Hiding. And you've seen where I live now and there's nowhere left to hide from you, so I don't know what I'm supposed to do with my hands."

Benjamin looked at the hand on Nicolas's knee. He didn't reach for it. He was learning, slowly, the difference between a repair and a rescue.

"Then we don't do anything tonight," he said. "You don't have to know."

"You say that like it's nothing."

"It's not nothing. It's a plan." He stood up, and his knee popped, and the cold came back in around him where the warmth had been. Down the block, a black car had pulled up along Centre Street and idled with its hazards on, and Benjamin noticed it the way he noticed everything—peripherally, filing it—and didn't think anything of it yet. "Come on. I'll walk you to the train."

"Benjamin."

"Yes."

"When you said the only real thing since you were nine." Nicolas was on his feet now, hands in his pockets, and his voice had gone back to its ordinary careful register, which was somehow the most revealing thing he'd done all day. "You're going to have to tell me. Eventually."

"I know."

"Because I'll ask."

"I know you will." Benjamin fell into step beside him, and their shoulders bumped once, and neither of them moved away. "Not tonight."

"Not tonight," Nicolas agreed, and they walked out of the square together under the courthouse lights, and neither of them noticed the black car pull out and follow at a distance, patient, unhurried, like a thing that had already been paid for and knew exactly how long it could afford to wait.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 74: The Answer · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads